Scholasticism.
The reason I had you guys read about scholasticism was that I wanted you to have some idea about what western intellectual life was like before modernity. Scholasticism was a broad, and complicated, intellectual movement that included a diverse range of thinkers and tendencies. It was dominated, however, by a set of academic practices that represented a way of thinking that is very different from the way of thinking that characterizes modern thought. In fact, we can divide western intellectual history at this point into a "scholastic" and a "modern" period.
The scholastic movement came into being as a consequence of the Christian domination of European political and economic life. Holding political power, the church took as its mission to ask of bringing everyone in Europe to accept Christianity by any means necessary. Opinions were divided on how to do this, and one school of thought wanted to ruthlessly suppress the newly rediscovered works of Aristotle. St. Thomas Aquinas saved Aristotle from the flames by producing work that appeared to show that Aristotle did not in fact contradict the Bible. Aquinas was a brilliant man, and his work was historically very important, especially in shaping the doctrines of the Catholic Church. However, many of those who followed Aquinas were somewhat less than brilliant, and it was they who established the basic practices of scholastic "philosophy."
The scholastic way of doing things was very different from what you are (hopefully) being taught in school. To the scholastics, accepted authorities could not be wrong. The Bible could not be wrong. Works by important and venerated Christian scholars could not be wrong, and so on. The only problem was that these texts appeared to contradict each other at various points. Since all of the texts were completely true, and true texts do not contradict each other, these apparent contradictions could not possibly be real. Therefore, scholastic philosophers took it as their task to show that these books really did not contradict each other.
Scholars compiled lists of apparent contradictions, called "sententiae," and then set about trying to show that the two writers actually did not disagree at all. This was done in two ways. First, scholars argued about the meanings of words, and tried to find, or perhaps invent, meanings for words that would allow the texts to be reconciled. Second, the texts might be subjected to logical analysis in an attempt to show that the apparent contradiction did not exist in reality, but was just an illusion in the mind of the reader. Now we get to the most fundamental way in which scholastic thought differs from modern thought. Consider the following argument:
1. These two books are both accepted as authorities.
2. Books that are accepted as authorities never disagree with each other.
3. The only way we could get these two books to agree with each other is if we accept that the word "fish" sometimes means "cantaloupe."
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Therefore, the word "fish" sometimes means "cantaloupe."
To the premodern mind, which is what most scholastic philosophers had, this kind of logic made perfect sense.
The following student blogs have good discussions of this issue:
http://waxingphilosopical.blogspot.com/
http://vodoubunny.blogspot.com/
http://tricia1043.blogspot.com/
http://cypresscollegephilosophy.blogspot.com/
Another premodern way of thinking is to regard reason as the servant of faith. To premodern thinkers, the role of reason is to demonstrate the truth of faith. To the premodern mind, God exists, and it is the job of the philosopher to prove that he does. If the careful and thorough application of reason does not prove the existence of God, then reason has failed. If the careful and thorough application of reason proves that God does not exist, then reason is being perverted in that it has been used for something that is the opposite of its natural function. To the premodern mind, such a perversion of reason is a serious moral wrong, and people who argue in the wrong way should not be listened to, and should probably be punished.
Also see the discussion of questions 8 and 9 on http://ryanroseisremotelycool.blogspot.com/,
and the response to question 3 on http://cypressphilosopher.blogspot.com/
This is not to say that there was no real philosophy going on in the scholastic period. The problem of universals was a real philosophical problem that went back to the time of Plato. I want to talk about it here because it illustrates another aspect of premodern thinking. This is the idea that completely intangible entities can and do exist. The problem of universals is hard to understand because it is the kind of problem that simply would not occur to people nowadays. The modern mind off the 21st century is familiar with such things as atoms, and pigments, and light rays, and so on, and can therefore give (or it least understand) physical explanations for observed phenomena. People in scholastic times did not know about any of this stuff, and so the kinds of explanation we would use now simply would not have been possible for them.
The problem of universals is this. Look around you and make a note of every red thing in your environment. How is it possible that all of these very different things can all be red? The main answer to this question was the doctrine of "realism." Realism held that there was some further entity (call it "Red Being") that really existed that somehow made all red things red. This "Red Being" really exists, even though it cannot be seen, touched, or experienced in any way. I want to emphasize that this is a weird idea. If the doctrine of realism of universals sounds normal and natural to you, you are probably not understanding it. The first thing you should realize is that no modern scientist and (hopefully) no modern philosopher believes in the doctrine of realism of universals. This doctrine says that there is something else, beyond red pigment, beyond red light, that makes red things red. Opposing this is the doctrine of nominalism. Nominalism holds that there is no Red Being, and that nothing exists to make red things red. We give all these things the name "red" because they resemble each other, or they fit the same concept, or they are the same type of thing, and that's all there is.
One way to see the difference between realism and nominalism of universals is think about what would exist if it so happened that all red things in the universe were destroyed. According to nominalism, there would be no redness left. For a nominalist, the only way redness can exist is if there is some red thing in the universe. For the realist, however, this is not so. For the realist, if all red things were destroyed, Red Being would still exist. It's true that no one would ever see any red, and that no one would have any means of physically detecting Red Being, but it would still exist. Hopefully, you are saying to yourself "that doesn't make sense. If something exists, then it is physically detectable." If you find yourself nodding along to this idea that, if things exist, then they are at least in principle physically detectable, then you have a modern mind.
There's good discussion of universals at the following student blogs.
http://waxingphilosopical.blogspot.com/
http://tricia1043.blogspot.com/
http://cypressphilosopher.blogspot.com/
http://cypresscollegephilosophy.blogspot.com/
There's another thoughtful analysis of this whole subject at http://heroinandapricots.blogspot.com/
To the premodern mind, the idea that things have to be physically detectable in order to be real is the idea that doesn't make sense. The next couple of units are at least partly about the transition from premodern to modern thinking in European society. I hope this was helpful.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment